A clearer shortlist

Compare the trade-offs.

Up to three tools, priced for your team with the same assumptions.

buttondown logo

buttondown

buttondown.com

Price clarity grade F, 10 out of 100
Cocomail logo

Cocomail

cocomail.cc

Price clarity grade B, 77 out of 100
Often compared with buttondown

The cost for your team

Published prices at your team size, updated as you type. Anything a vendor did not state is called out, not guessed.

Must-have features Pick one to hide plans that do not list it

buttondown logobuttondownPrice clarity grade F, 10 out of 100

—

No published pricing yet

Cocomail logoCocomailPrice clarity grade B, 77 out of 100

$4 /month

Starter plan · $48 a year

Clearest pricing

Paid plans as your team grows

Each tool at its cheapest paid plan for that many people. Where lines cross, the cheaper choice changes

Every plan, line by line
Plan costs based on your requirements
Tool / planMonthlyPer yearWhat this assumes
buttondown logobuttondownNo pricing recorded yet. Check the official site, or ask the owner to add it.
Cocomail logoCocomail

StarterCheapest fit

Flat subscription

$4$48

Automatically extracted from the linked pricing source. Seat allowances, usage limits, taxes and terms are not confirmed — check them with the provider.

Confirmed on this plan: 2,500 emails/month, Unlimited contacts, 1 custom domain, Rich text editor, Full template library, Subscribe form

Cocomail logoCocomail

Creator

Flat subscription

$12$144

Automatically extracted from the linked pricing source. Seat allowances, usage limits, taxes and terms are not confirmed — check them with the provider.

Confirmed on this plan: 25,000 emails/month, Unlimited contacts, 3 custom domains, Full template library, Tag-based segments, Open & click tracking

Cocomail logoCocomail

Pro

Flat subscription

$32$384

Automatically extracted from the linked pricing source. Seat allowances, usage limits, taxes and terms are not confirmed — check them with the provider.

Confirmed on this plan: 100,000 emails/month, Unlimited contacts, 10 custom domains, Full template library + custom HTML, Tag-based segments, Open, click, bounce & delivery tracking

buttondown logo

buttondown

Best fit

Creators who want to run a newsletter and publish to their audience from a simple backend.

Trade-offs

Not yet documented

Integrations / export

Discord., Memberful., YouTube.

Cocomail logo

Cocomail

Best fit

Writers tired of paying for list size or getting overwhelmed by features.

Trade-offs

Not yet documented

Integrations / export

Mailchimp, Substack, Beehiiv, and Kit imports are supported.